Monday, June 2, 2008
His Scimitar Childhood
Shallow America
Even when we focus on radical Islam, we are woefully ignorant about it. Unlike Communism, which we broadly understood was shaped by Marx and applied by Lenin, Stalin, Mao, and others, we don't know from whence radical Islam came. With few exceptions among elites and the public, we don't recognize that terrorist attacks on the United States and the West over the last 30 years are the latest phase of a 1,400-year struggle by radical Islam to defeat the forces of modernity and return society to the time of Mohammed. We don't know the interconnected ideologies and roles of the Muslim Brotherhood, the Whahhabis, and the Khomeinists in reviving this struggle in the 20th Century.
Blissfully ignorant of the beliefs, the outlook, the goals, and the methods of our adversaries, we are profoundly un-serious about the dangers that they represent. We are un-serious about the military commitment, the resources, and the measures required to defeat radical Islam both abroad and at home. Democrat, Republican, and independent - we are all un-serious. But our political affiliation determines just what it is we are un-serious about. To put it another way, Democrats are un-serious about some aspects of the challenge ahead while Republicans are un-serious about others.
Sunday, June 1, 2008
Present Crisis - Dry Tinder
It is tempting to find the present crisis in the Democratic Party amusing. But this would be a mistake from the viewpoint of mimetic theory. Not only are ALL of us living in the time of scandal and sacrificial preparation, but we take for granted too much that we are somehow exempt in the United States from the kind of social devolution and violence that we see elsewhere.Westerners while living in the "Christ-haunted" ethos of the bare ruined choirs of Christendom rarely can articulate let alone thematize the foundational presuppositions that lent us freedom from elements of the primitive Sacred: the paganism that is premised on force majeure, pantheism and animism. But rest assured: if we continue to throw out the Judeo-Christian antinomy for paganism in our legislatures, media, and courts of law, we shall most surely see it in its hydra-like manifestations raining fire across the delapidated West.
Don't say I didn't warn you. Or, don't you know paganism when you see it in post-modern nihilism and the Scimitar?
Saturday, May 31, 2008
Existential Dread, or Hope
"Out of the darkness of my life, so much frustrated, I put before you the one great thing to love on earth: the Blessed Sacrament ... There you will find romance, glory, honour, fidelity, and the true way of all your loves on earth, and more than that: Death: by the divine paradox, that which ends life, and demands the surrender of all, and yet by the taste (or foretaste) of which alone can what you seek in your earthly relationships (love, faithfulness, joy) be maintained, or take on that complexion of reality, of eternal endurance, which every man's heart desires."
- Edward Schillebeeckx (quoted by Gil Bailie)
Blair - Using "Religion" for Peace
Fortunately, Blair is now a Catholic. Here is the greatest hope for his new project.
Culture of Death Candidate Opines
A video of Barack Hussein Obama in which he says that the Christian right "drives people apart." Perhaps one might say, "Cafeteria Christian-Leftist Politician Drives People Apart?"
Friday, May 30, 2008
Paganism, Then and Now - Pt. III
But, people being what they (we) are, Girard shows that myths worldwide show not only the necessary scapegoat mechanism at the heart of culture, but also cultural breakdown from time to time. Gil Bailie, for my money the best popularizer of mimetic theory, explicates in his book, Violence Unveiled (Crossroads, 1996), a myth of the Toltec peoples that shows exactly this crisis: a time when an "economic" sacrificial mechanism needing only one or a few victims moved to an inefficient and murderous cultural development - one that usually signals the death-throes of a culture. (This myth of Quetzalcoatl and Tezcatlipoca can be read on pp. 99ff.)
Western civilization is now by all accounts in this stage of cultural dilapidation. Robert Hamerton-Kelly says that a certain indicator of a culture that is losing its centripetal power to hold its people together socially and psychologically is seen in a bipartite characteristic - its need to throw more victims into the sacrificial mechanism, or more prestigious victims: genocide or regicide. Democracy itself, he theorizes, is the cultural concretization of the death of kings (Louis XVI, Charles I). The 20th century shows graphically the decline of the West using this indicator.
What Girard discovered in his groundbreaking studies in cultural anthropology - "mimetic theory" - was the effect of the Gospel in history. He was flabbergasted as any scholar would be to turn in his literary and mimetic studies to the New Testament and find that the Bible seemed to understand the dynamics of mimetic theory as well or better than he. (I suggested strongly to the reader both Girard's Violence and the Sacred [Johns Hopkins, 1977] and The Scapegoat [Johns Hopkins, 1986] in this regard.) I won't go into all of his findings, but this is a quote from his book, Things Hidden Since the Foundation of the World:
“Jesus is not there in order to stress once again in his own person the unified violence of the sacred. He is not there to ordain and govern like Moses; he is not there to unify people around him, to forge its unity in the crucible of rites and prohibitions. But on the contrary, to turn this long page of human history once and for all" [204]
How "satanic"? Recall: etymologically, the Greek word "satan" is synonymous with "the accuser." It is the accusatory gesture that establishes the first notions of human culture ("It's HIS fault!"); the murder or casting out of the scapegoated victim is the second part of originary culture-making scene. By definition, Satan is the "murderer and liar from the beginning" who creates all the world's kingdoms and powers (Jn 8). Astonishingly, the Greek word used in the New Testament for the Holy Spirit, "paraklete" means "counselor for the defense," "comforter," one who stands with the accused.
Girard was overwhelmed to see in the Gospels an alternative to the conventional cultures of the world universally depicted in the anthropological record. This new Kingdom was initiated, said the Church (unified for 1,500 years +/-), by a loving, forgiving, and self-disclosing God who went to the extreme measure of becoming one-with us (the Incarnation), suffering our human bloodthirstiness to the point of death (the Crucifixion), and rising from the dead not to reek havoc, but to offer repentance and a new Way of being in the world (the Resurrection and giving of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost); namely, the ecclesia, the Church. This Way did not expel or murder a victim or victims to convene itself (ask what cultures demand this today). Rather, the Church into which this Risen Lord invites all peoples convenes by gathering around the "lamb slain since the foundation of the world," his Altar, his Word, his Love. The Sacrifice of the Mass he instituted so that we would not again seek human victims to do the satanic thing.
Where has this Gospel brought us? At its high point, it brought to flower Christendom. Yes, reform was essential and called-for, but the so-called "reformation" began a scourge that has led Christendom to the brink of breathtaking demise. Shall it find unity and a restoration? Or, will the primitive Sacred swallow it in its two-pincer vice-grips of postmodern nihilism, on the one hand, and the religion of the Scimitar on the other once and for all?
Shakespeare Among the Ruins

Essential reading. Essential viewing. Far and away better than the The DaVinci Code tripe and piffle. You couldn't make this stuff up!
Paganism, Then and Now - Pt. II
Girard's mimetic theory posits an originary scene that pre-dates culture; meaning, there is not yet any "us". A prime tenet of mimetic theory is that humans are "mimetic" - contagiously imitative - as are all primates. That's why we "ape" one another. But to current western attitudes, we'd rather die than admit that we copy anybody. Since Rousseau, we endeavor even to hide this fact from ourselves; bbut if we are honest, we all have models. Madison Avenue knows it about us, however, quite well.
So, being mimetic before culture, Girard proposes the acquisitive gesture: somebody reaches for a delicacy - fruit, sexual partner, whatever - and others copy the desirous gesture. But there is a limited commodity. So, Hobbes's "war of all against all" kicks in.
When it looks as though all hell will break loose, the acquisitive gesture that was so contagious is replaced by a peace-making gesture: the ACCUSATORY gesture. Somebody (prior to language, a product of culture) points and says, 'All this is HIS fault," and this gesture is mimicked with lightning like rapidity.
The beginning of culture! WE suddenly all agree about something and we have a culprit. This is the lowest common denominator of culture: a victim we can all agree to expel and/or murder. Girard calls this, "unanimity minus one." The esprit de corp literally develops around the dead body of the one who is the agreed-upon wrong-doer.
This only brings us to the very beginning of culture. The crowd feels very good about itself after the murder, but also in Girard's estimation, very humbled. How could peace come about so abruptly, after chaos was so close? Clearly a god did it. Indeed, the victim who we thought caused the problem came to bring us peace by allowing us to kill him.
This is the beginning of a tripartite set of essentials for human culture: myth, ritual, and prohibition.
The myth is the story of how the god came in our time of distress, allowed us to kill him, and brought us peace and social harmony. Myth allows us to feel good, even "righteous", about our violence: the god caused it. We did the right thing in killing him; it is what he expected and wanted us to do.
The ritual is the beginning of what is religion, anthropologically speaking: religare - literally, a binding back, to the founding event of culture. It is the formalizing that originary founding violence in a ritual complete with priesthood to see that it is remembered correctly and efficaciously.
When things again become chaotic, socially and psychologically, the priesthood ratchets it up a few notches (release of violent prisoners, etc.), then the originally scene is played out again using a certifiable "bad guy" as victim. Caiaphus in John's Gospel says it well: "Better that one shd die than the whole nation be destroyed." The ritual re-establishes order, and, when done well, it is economic: only a single victim is sufficient.
Prohibition, the third element, is what keeps culture from getting too near flash-points that could ignite social chaos before the priesthood can contain things with ritual. Thus, conventional cultures always place taboos around murder, adultery, etc. - those things that can bring social solidarity to its knees.
These are all elements of traditional pagan culture, in Girard's understanding. Western civilization certainly contains such elements, but Girard discovered something in his studies, long after he developed a thorough-going theory: the Christian faith.
He didn't assume the truth of the gospel, he discovered it well after his studies took him, finally, to the New Testament and, thence, back to the Old. The biblical spirit is very much at-odds with the pagan spirit of what he calls "the primitive Sacred."
Part III - The effect of the Gospel on history, culture, and violence.
Paganism, Then and Now - Pt. I
Let us look at the phenomenon of paganism. In three posts, I will examine its characteristics, first from a psychoanalytic point of view, given to us by the former President of the C. G. Jung Foundation, Jeffrey Burke Satinover. Dr. Satinover also served as a lecturer at both Harvard and Yale Medical Schools, and now resides in Israel. In parts two and three, I will attempt to lay out some of the stunning anthropological insights of the French scholar, René Girard. Girard approached and compiled what he called "mimetic theory" first as a historian (PhD, Indiana University) and then as a literary critic. Dr. Girard was inducted into the Académie française in March 2005. Both men, coming from their respective disciplines, conclude that
the pagan is our human default position, culturally and psychologically. Without the influence of the biblical spirit, Satinover says, the pagan contains the following:
"First, of course, paganism is polytheistic. Each individual (or in more primitive, homogeneous societies, each group) feels himself subject to his own god or goddess. At a practical level, this means that the distinctive values, standards, goals, and laws of each deity govern the lives of that deity’s worshipers. Thus pagan society is polyvalent: a single moral standard does not govern the lives of men, and except by force majeure, no god, and no corresponding set of human values, is superior to any other. And, as a consequence, pagan societies tend to become inegalitarian. For different standards for different groups is something that inevitably leads to factional competition; and in time force majeure indeed becomes the rule-might soon comes to make right. Zeus rules because he is strongest, and for no other reason; he is certainly not the wisest.
"As we know, pagan society is pantheistic or animistic: gods and goddesses inhabit the natural world and are one with it; nature itself is worshipped as divine; there is no serious distinction between creature and creator. Again, on a practical level, this means that men worship not only the nature "out there," they also worship their own nature, which is to say, their instincts: e.g., hunger, sex, and aggression, and more generally, pleasure. In thus spiritualizing the instincts, pagan worship therefore tends naturally to the violent, the hedonistic, and the orgiastic. Pagan religious ritual arouses the instincts, especially sexuality and aggression, to the keenest possible pitch. In the subsequent gratification of these instincts, the greatest possible pleasure and hence also the highest level of religious ecstasy is meant to be achieved. Violent intoxication, temple prostitution, the ritual slaughter of enemies, self-mutilation, even child sacrifice: all these historical phenomena can be understood not as pathological, but as predictable end-points to the unfettering of human nature..."
What this means for today is not measured necessarily in self-labeled neo-pagan's behavior and/or beliefs. Rather, they are the demonstrable effects of a rejection of the biblical faiths, Judaism and Christianity, in what was once a culture greatly influenced not by our fall-back pagan origins, but a Judeo-Christian ethos at-odds with the aims of paganism for 2,000 years.
But as Anglican bishop Michael Nazir-Ali notes, the slippage of biblical influence has created a vacuum that is being filled by two great pincers of the primitive Sacred: postmodern nihilism and the Scimitar.
In part II, I will review Girard's perspective on hominization and the origins of human culture, and how culture world-wide contains the visible remnants of its violent origins.
Neuhaus - CA's "Raw Judicial Power"
Crisis of Distinctions - Progressive Pipe Dream
Yet more evidence of the "sacrificial preparation" proceeding apace with the requisite "crisis of distinctions" - ”Guv strikes state's gender-specific restrooms”Girard's mimetic theory posits that such break-downs of prohibitions are not only necessary but predictable prerequisites that lead to ritualized re-enactment of the founding violence of a culture. At least, that's the game plan hard-wired into conventional culture. However, few or no such politicians as the Colorado "governor" in the above article have knowledge of this innate sacrificial mechanism at the heart of human culture. For such "progressives" they are doing the next forward-thinking "thing" in the name of multiculturalist ideology - namely, "tolerance" - in what they think will lead to but never call "utopia". Once it is said, the silliness is too apparent, even for "progressives".
Conventional cultures knew very well the reasons for their prohibitions or taboos: it was to keep the populace from straying too dangerously close to flash-points such as murder, adultery, and other such staple (cf. the Book of Leviticus for examples). They knew that such trespasses could lead to the fracturing of communities and societies in escalating, spiraling retribution and retaliation. (Think Hatfields and McCoys, Palestineans and Israelis, Northern Ireland Catholics and Protestants.) The "progressive" pipe dream of eliminating all such distinctions as sexual identity, gender specificity - the ancient yet hard-wired cultural taboos - is a predictable lead-up to the cultural chaos, the "sacrificial preparation," just prior to the orchestrated sacrificial event by a priesthood.
But where is the priesthood of the primitive Sacred today? Those who remember and are trained to carry out such sacrificial violence? The faiths of the Bible have ever tried to move humanity away from the primitive Sacred (read some René Girard if you don't think so), starting with God's words to Cain ("Your brother's blood cries out to me from the ground.") and leading to the Cross ("Father, forgive them; they know not what they do.") But the "priests" of a another so-called monotheistic religion are trying sacrifice all the time. Read the headlines: beheadings, "honor killings," jihad, qital.
Western "progressives" never, ever put together two words which are the endzone of their "tolerance" efforts: "human" and "sacrifice". Their myth still blinds them to it; else how can they miss what Old Testament prophets would spot in a heartbeat - child sacrifice to Moloch?
So, tell me again, why is this man in the picture smiling?
