Wednesday, May 13, 2009

Stumper of the day

Jules Crittendon asks, Should people who deny fundamental biological facts and claim to be of the opposite gender be entrusted with large public conveyances that carry dozens of commuters?

Music, Mozart, Polyphony, & Western Civ

Interesting and sage comments from Fjordmann:
The Christian Church was the dominant social institution in post-Roman Europe and deeply affected the future development of European music. The ancient Greek system of notation had apparently been forgotten by the seventh century AD, when Isidore of Seville (ca. 560-636) wrote that “Unless sounds are remembered by man, they perish, for they cannot be written down.” But with the development of complex chants, what was needed to stabilize them was notation, a way to write down the music. The earliest surviving European books of chant with music notation date from the ninth century. During the early Christian era, the Classical legacy was used, but modified. From the Jews came the practices of singing psalms and chanting Scripture. Church leaders drew on Greek musical theory but rejected pagan customs, and elevated worship over entertainment and singing over instrumental music.

It is instructive to consider the fact that Middle Eastern Muslims, too, had access to Greek musical theory, yet they decided not use it, just like they did not utilize the Greek artistic legacy. Both music and pictorial arts were integrated into religious worship in Christian Europe in a way that never happened in the Islamic world. In fact, it was Gregorian chant and the growth of polyphonic music in medieval European monasteries and cathedrals which established the musical tradition that would eventually culminate in the works of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart and Ludwig van Beethoven centuries later. There was no Mozart or Beethoven in the Islamic world, just like there was no Copernicus, Galileo or Newton.

The invention of musical notation enabled musicians to build upon the work of the past. It may have been a necessary condition for the expansion and development of musical expression, but it is not alone sufficient to explain later advances. The discovery of the connection between mathematical ratios and musical intervals attributed to Pythagoras – and independently the Chinese – was important, but not as important as polyphony. According to Charles Murray, “Just as linear perspective added depth to the length and breadth of painting, polyphony added, metaphorically, a vertical dimension to the horizontal line of melody.”
Read all here.

There you go again

As I've said before about falling into the sin of despair, Sherry Weddell reminds us of these blasts from the past.

Tuesday, May 12, 2009

Bailie, Emmaus Road Initiative, BXVI

Gil Bailie, friend and mentor, continues his invaluable work in speaking engagements across the United States this month. Catch his May Emmaus Road Initiative talk at a venue near you.

Gil posts this powerful talk given by Pope Benedict at the Holocaust Museum - a most worthwhile 7 minute investment of your time.

It's one of life's simple joys to be able to support a friend, educator, and brother in Christ like Gil Bailie.

Smile real big and wave

The push back at campuses where I Won is speaking is starting. Will he even notice, or will his handlers insure he does not? After all, like Nixon watching football and ignoring peace protests, he apparently hasn't heard or seen anything about tea parties.

Sunday, May 10, 2009

Happy Mothers' Day

Or Grovel, more like. Forget It

Jordanian clerics expressed disappointment that Pope Benedict XVI in an address to Muslim leaders on Saturday failed to offer a new apology for remarks seen as targeting Islam.

"We wanted him to clearly apologise," Sheikh Yusef Abu Hussein, mufti of the southern city of Karak, told AFP after the pope's address in Amman's huge Al-Hussein Mosque.

Read more here.

Never Forget It

"I, as a Christian, always say that I am Arabic, Jordanian and Christian," Nader Twal, a Christian tour guide in Jordan, explained. "We Christians make up 3% [of the population of Jordan], Catholic are 1.5%. We see in this visit a support for the presence of Christians, we who've been here 2,000 years.

Saturday, May 9, 2009

GKC - The Macbeths

"Make a morbid decision and you will only become more morbid; do a lawlesss thing and you will only get into an atmosphere much more suffocating than that of law. Indeed, it is a mistake to speak of a man as 'breaking out.' The lawless man never breaks out; he breaks in. He smashes a door and finds himself in another room, he smashes a wall and finds himself in a yet smaller one. The more he shatters the more his habitation shrinks. Where he ends you may read in the end of Macbeth.

"For us moderns, therefore, the first philosophical significance of the play is this; that our life is one thing and that our lawless acts limit us; every time we break a law we make a limitation. In some strange way hidden in the deeps of human psychology, if we build our palace on some unknown wrong it turns very slowly into our prison. Macbeth at the end of the play is not merely a wild beast; he is a caged wild beast."

- G. K. Chesterton [ht: Joseph Pearce]

Crisis of Distinctions - Dymphna

Dymphna pulls back far enough for us to see the convulsing cultural upheaval surrounding gay marriage in her well-written gay marriage, welcome to the vomitorium.

Any way you slice it

Friday, May 8, 2009

Connect the Dots

This and this should be read carefully and cool-headedly, remembering that Dr. Jeffrey Burke Satinover, formerly of both the Harvard and Yale medical schools, laid out the political reasons that the APA did not include homosexuality as a character disorder any longer in its Diagnostic and Statistics Manual IV. The multitudinous scientific reasons for including it were over-ridden by the shrill caucus claiming victimhood, but the scientific reasons now politically incorrect are voiceless and unheeded.

The unfettered adulation of the human will and worship of the instincts is now the highest good in dying western culture, gaining power by law and in negative imitation of Magisterial truth. Where it will end, and where it has always ended, is the place of sacrifice.

Burke, ND, and Epistemology

St. George and the Dragon. 1868 - Sir Edward Burne-Jones, PRB

With this, I will now say that Fr. Jenkins, president of the University of Notre Dame, is in a peck of trouble. Not only is he out on a limb with the saw in his own hand half way through it - the limb, not his hand - but he has created a public scandal that qualifies as a mortal sin insofar that it has divided the faithful (and so-so faithful).

Our Lord himself had grave promises about such sin:
"Things that cause sin will inevitably occur, but woe to the person through whom they occur. It would be better for him if a millstone were put around his neck and he be thrown into the sea than for him to cause one of these little ones to sin."
- Luke 17,1b-2
Rest assured. There is judgment, there is eternal consequence to our decisions and actions; regardless of the functional atheists who call themselves Christians and jettison all the faith and morals that Mother Church guards and protects till the end of time.

What we can be assured of from their kind is more outrage, damage, and pushing of the squirm-line in actions like this or this.

You see, quite simply, without a reliable source of epistemological certainty, "truth" is whatever or whomever has the greatest power with which to determine the terms of discourse.

That the Catholic Church has strode through history this long, outlasting all earthly governments (you really can't call China unchanging, now) during her tenure; that the Catholic Church has done, is doing, and will do so much good in the world compared to all other mere human institutions (think of the 20th century utopian projects of Stalin, et al. I'll live with the Inquisition and I vote for the Crusades - we were there centuries before the Muslims); that the Catholic Church is the keeper of faith and morals discarded and rejected bit by bit by all other christianities - and I am indelibly happy to be in full communion with Mother Church.

Notre Dame needs to put up or shut up. Academia does not set the terms of discourse. The Church does.

Guilty as Charged

Here are two irresistible headlines fairly begging to be posted for the record: