Saturday, February 21, 2009

Scruton - Defence of the West

Roger Scruton lays out a manifesto for those who are concerned about the way of approaching one of Christendom's oldest and - now again - aggressive foes.

Put simply, the citizens of Western states have lost their appetite for foreign wars; they have lost the hope of scoring any but temporary victories; and they have lost confidence in their way of life. Indeed, they are no longer sure what that way of life requires of them.

At the same time, they have been confronted with a new opponent, one who believes that the Western way of life is profoundly flawed, and perhaps even an offense against God. In a "fit of absence of mind," Western societies have allowed this opponent to gather in their midst; sometimes, as in France, Britain, and the Netherlands, in ghettos which bear only tenuous and largely antagonistic relations to the surrounding political order. And in both America and Europe there has been a growing desire for appeasement: a habit of public contrition; an acceptance, though with heavy heart, of the censorious edicts of the mullahs; and a further escalation in the official repudiation of our cultural and religious inheritance. Twenty years ago, it would have been inconceivable that the archbishop of Canterbury would give a public lecture advocating the incorporation of Islamic religious law (shari'ah) into the English legal system. Today, however, many people consider this to be an arguable point, and perhaps the next step on the way to peaceful compromise.

All this suggests that we in the West stand on the edge of a dangerous period of concession, in which the legitimate claims of our own culture and inheritance will be ignored or downplayed in an attempt to prove our peaceful intentions. It will be some time before the truth will be allowed to play its all-important role of rectifying our current mistakes and preparing the way for the next ones. This means that it is more necessary than ever for us to rehearse the truth and come to a clear and objective understanding of what is at stake. I will, therefore, spell out in what follows some of the critical features of the Western inheritance which must be understood and defended in our current confrontation. Each of these features marks a point of contrast, and possibly of conflict, with the traditional Islamic vision of society, and each has played a vital part in creating the modern world. Islamist belligerence stems from having found no secure place in that world, and from turning for refuge to precepts and values that are at odds with the Western way of life. This does not mean that we should renounce or repudiate the distinguishing features of our civilization, as many would have us do. On the contrary, it means that we must be all the more vigilant in their defense ...

Read all from the Catholic Education Resource Center here.

UPDATE: Mark Shea redirects Scruton here.

2 comments:

David Nybakke said...

Somewhere in the article he might have slipped in what truly sets us apart, that is our shining example that you aptly describe and here where Gil uses Lee Harris' words to fine use.

People like research professors in academia need to begin to spell out what really is important and not be so oppressed by philosophy and theories that is often put to misused under the stronghold of polical correctness: as the example of Scruton writing only about the Christian inheritance from theory angle but not as a person.

Athos said...

I seem to remember a fellow back in the mid-90's - fascinating talks on - what was it now? "mimetic theory?" Very little confessional material, even in his book, Violence Unveiled. Pretty academical talks.

Turns out he was well on his way to reclaiming his "shining example," Our Lord, and now we can't get him to stop quoting BXVI and Von Balthsazar!

(Not true - this month's ERI talk brings in THE BACCHAE and is thoroughgoing MT, Gospel, and all that the early talks had that was captivating. Hope you can make it!)