Tuesday, March 24, 2009

Bishop D'Arcy on Not Our Dame

The timing could not be apt, as Bishop John D'Arcy points out in his statement regarding President Obama being invited, and accepting the invitation, to speak at Notre Dame:
Even as I continue to ponder in prayer these events, which many have found shocking, so must Notre Dame. Indeed, as a Catholic University, Notre Dame must ask itself, if by this decision it has chosen prestige over truth.

Tomorrow, we celebrate as Catholics the moment when our Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ, became a child in the womb of his most holy mother. Let us ask Our Lady to intercede for the university named in her honor, that it may recommit itself to the primacy of truth over prestige.
Read all …

Shock and Outrage

A somewhat bemused essay in the Washington Times wherein the French and other denizens of modern times discover to their appalled displeasure and discombobulation that the Pope is Catholic!!

Collective Violence - a new study

Collective religious rituals, not religious devotion, spur support for suicide attacks. So says a new study in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science. This substantiates it.

For students of René Girard's mimetic theory, this is not a surprise rather a corroboration.

Not Our Dame II

Stephen Barr at First Things weighs in on the Not Our Dame Scandal here.

Monday, March 23, 2009

Thank You, WHO

Holy guacamole. Karen Hall has posted a video that a brave African American woman made here. Must see!

Burden of Proof

The Wall Street Journal's Tawfik Hamid says Islam Needs to Prove It's a Religion of Peace. The Holy Father said much the same in his recent address to Muslims in Cameroon.

I would say the burden of proof lies squarely at the feet of the Scimitar. Yes, it is "guilt by association," but the Scimitar has ever proselytized by the sword, intimidation, and allegiance to the primitive sacred's dependence on blood sacrifice.

Till then, Mr. Hamid, above, is correct.

Gothic Glory

A big hat tip to the Anchoress who shares a gothic cathedral in which the Crucifix of the rood screen is illuminated only twice a year.

To know about probably the most faithful architect of Mother Church in 19th century England, read this, or search this weblog for Pugin.

Sunday, March 22, 2009

Not Our Dame

As most of us know, I Won is slated to speak at The University of Notre Dame for commencement. Having gone to its website and written my displeasure, I awaited a timely comment from those slap-happy denizens at Shrine of the Holy Whapping. It wasn't a long wait - Emily posted.

Okay? okay. Well, folks, this one is pretty bad, and no doubt about it. Now, on the one hand, of course, I would imagine that Notre Dame, like many other major universities, invites the sitting President as a matter of course. They may not have expected an acceptance any more than usual. I am not pointing this out to excuse the invitation, because, of course, one would hope that there is much thought put into any honor bestowed by the University. I am merely noting that he may not have been singled out particularly. It’s still inexcusable, as they’ve managed to bring scandal to many, as well as marring the exercises by causing many graduates to question whether they can even attend their own commencement in good conscience.

I gather that the administration's take is that we need to engage the president in dialogue, and that inviting him to speak somehow fulfills this. I imagine that I do not need to point out the flaws in this argument to our readership, as he is being honored by the university, and not merely invited to lecture or debate. Keeping the lines of communication open is always good; but I doubt they’re turning the commencement exercises into a town hall debate.

The flaws in the argument having been duly noted, I think that being aware of their rationale can be helpful in voicing our objections. It is true, of course, that we are called as Catholics to engage those with whom we disagree. The problem is that the opportunity for scandal to the Faithful has been ignored, perhaps willfully, by the administration. The argument for inviting him is rather nuanced, if flawed, and it behooves arguments against his coming to be well thought out and address more nuanced points. As a commenter elsewhere noted:

"saying ‘ND thinks it's okay to kill babies!’ fails to recognize the complexity of the situation. Something like ‘ND isn't taking Obama's policies toward life issues into serious enough consideration’ is a much better argument.”

The difference between an ordinary speaking engagement or debate and the honor of giving a commencement address ought to be highlighted, as well as our duty to avoid giving scandal. We are not trying to retreat to the ghetto, and we do need to live in the world, but given the at least potential appearance of endorsing the president's pro-abortion actions, the choice was a highly imprudent one, at best.

Read it all.

UPDATE: Father Ralph McInerny, author and soon to retire professor at The University of Notre Dame, writes of Obama's invitation at The Catholic Thing, here posted by Father Z with his usual level of commentary.

Pogàny

They Went WHERE

Incredible Lightness of I Won

Peggy Noonan's snapshot of the Last Self-Help Administration heretofore:

He is willowy when people yearn for solid, reed-like where they hope for substantial, a bright older brother when they want Papa, cool where they probably prefer warmth. All of which may or may not hurt Barack Obama in time. Lincoln was rawboned, prone to the blues and freakishly tall, with a new-grown beard that refused to become an assertion and remained, for four years, a mere and constant follicular attempt. And he did OK.

Such impressions—coolness, slightness—can come to matter only if they capture or express some larger or more meaningful truth. At the moment they connect, for me, to something insubstantial and weightless in the administration's economic pronouncements and policies. The president seems everywhere and nowhere, not fully focused on the matters at hand ...
Read all ...

Saturday, March 21, 2009

Future Primitive

The man-made, scapegoat-rich environment of the present financial crisis has shown that technology - or "smarter math" as the new IBM ads would have it - does not mitigate against human fallenness. It exacerbates it exponentially.

As mimetic theory posits on the basis of the archaeological record, the ignoring and/or rejection of the Judeo-Christian influence that is haute couture will not result in the progressivists' pipe dream of a secular-science based utopia; far from it. What we can expect is a newer, more technologically enhanced paganism. Take my word for it; it won't be pretty.

Solitude

The sense of panic and abject fear is palpable today. The internet and endless supply of news on cable television, while valuable, can turn TVs and computers into veritable palantiri – never lying, but always leading the merely mortals who see what is to be seen there to misunderstanding.

From this despair and gnawing helplessness, I suggest setting aside time each day for solitude: prayer before the Blessed Sacrament (if feasible), private contemplative prayer, lectio divina, the Rosary, even viewing Into Great Silence; in short, time to "be still and know that I AM God" (Ps 46,10).

The late Henri Nouwen reflects on the utter necessity of such solitude - for sanity, civility, community, and service in the world in his important book, Clowning in Rome.
How can solitude help our world? How can we, by practicing solitude, bring love into the world? In our emergency-oriented society, fear and anger have become powerful forces. Not only do we see ... daily ... people driven together by fear or bound together by anger, but we also start to realize that many of us in our families and communities are plagued by a restlessness tainted by fear and anger. We search to satisfy a growing need for community that offers a sense of belonging, a place where frustrations can be expressed, disappointments shared, and pains healed. We who in the past felt quite secure and self-confident today suffer from self-doubt, and sometimes from a deep sense of powerlessness ...

For this reason we will take a very careful look at the importance of solitude in our lives. It might be that by de-emphasizing solitude in favor of the urgent needs of our world, we have endangered the very basis of our lives as Christian witnesses.

Waterhouse - PRB

Spring (1900) - John William Waterhouse